Over two years ago, an osteopathic physician by the name of Sherri Tenpenny created a stir when she told the Ohio state legislature that Covid vaccines magnetize people or cause them to “interface with 5G towers.”[1] What became apparent at that time was that Tenpenny was herself a virulent disease vector of disinformation. Indeed, in its March 2021 report, the Center for Countering Digital Hate listed Tenpenny as a top anti-vaccination shyster. As a social media vector, she is ranked in the top dozen “influencers.”[2] No surprise, in addition to bloviating about Covid vaccines, someone with such quirkly non-evidence based opinions turns up in litigation as an expert witness.[3]
At the time of Tenpenny’s ludicrous testimony before the Ohio state legislature, one astute observer remarked that the AMA Ethical Guidelines specify that medical societies and medical licensing boards are responsible for maintaining high standards for medical testimony, and must assess “claims of false or misleading testimony.”[4] When the testimony is false or misleading, these bodies should discipline the offender “as appropriate.”[5]
The State Medical Board of Ohio stepped up to its responsibility. After receiving hundreds (roughly 350) complaints about Tenpenny’s testimony, the Ohio Board launched an investigation of Tenpenny, who was first licensed as an osteopathic physician in 1984.[6] The Board’s investigators tried to contact Tenpenny, who apparently evaded engaging with them. Eventually, Thomas Renz, a lawyer for Tenpenny informed the Board that Tenpenny “[d]eclin[ed] to cooperate in the Board’s bad faith and unjustified assault on her licensure, livelihood, and constitutional rights cannot be construed as an admission of any allegations against her.”
After multiple unsuccessful attempts to reach Tenpenny, the Board issued a citation, in 2022, against her for stonewalling the investigation. Tenpenny requested an administrative hearing, set for April 2023, when she would be able to submit her defense in writing. The Board refused to let Tenpenny evade questioning, and suspended her license for failure to comply with the investigation. According to the Board’s Order, “Dr. Tenpenny did not simply fail to cooperate with a Board investigation, she refused to cooperate. *** And that refusal was based on her unsupported and subjective belief regarding the Board’s motive for the investigation. Licensees of the Board cannot simply refuse to cooperate in investigations because they decide they do not like what they assume is the reason for the investigation.”[7]
According to the Board’s Order, Tenpenny has been fined $3,000, and she must satisfy the Board’s conditions before applying for reinstatement. The Ohio Board’s decision is largely based upon a procedural ruling that flowed from Tenpenny’s refusal to cooperate with the Board’s investigation. Most state medical boards have done little to nothing to address the substance of physician misconduct arising out of the COVID pandemic. This month, American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) announced that it was revoking the board certifications of two physicians, Drs. Paul Marik and Pierre Kory, members of the Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance, for engaging in promoting disinformation and invalid opinions about therapies for COVID-19 opinions.[8] Ron Johnson, the quack senator from Wisconsin, predictably and transparently criticized the ABIM’s action with an ad hominem attack on the ABIM as the action of a corporate cabal. Quack physicians of course have a first amendment right to say whatever, but their licensure and their board certification are contingent on basic competence. Both the state boards and the certifying private groups have the right and responsibility to revoke licenses and privileges when physicians demonstrate incompetence and callousness in the face of a pandemic. There is no unqualified right to professional licenses or certifications.
[1] Andrea Salcedo, “A doctor falsely told lawmakers vaccines magnetize people: ‘They can put a key on their forehead. It sticks’,” Washington Post (June 9, 2021); Andy Downing, “What an exceedingly dumb time to be alive,” Columbus Alive (June 10, 2021); Jake Zuckerman, “She says vaccines make you magnetized. This West Chester lawmaker invited her testimony, chair says,” Ohio Capital Journal (July 14, 2021).
[2] The Disinformation Dozen (2021),
[3] Shaw v. Sec’y Health & Human Servs., No. 01-707V, 2009 U.S. Claims LEXIS 534, *84 n.40 (Fed. Cl. Spec. Mstr. Aug. 31, 2009) (excluding expert witness opinion testimony from Tenpenny).
[4] “Epistemic Virtue – Dropping the Dime on Tenpenny” Tortini (July 18, 2021).
[5] A.M.A. Code of Medical Ethics Opinion 9.7.1.
[6] Michael DePeau-Wilson, “Doc Who Said COVID Vax Magnetized People Has License Suspended,” MedPageToday (Aug. 11, 2023); David Gorski, “The Ohio State Medical Board has finally suspended the medical license of antivax quack Sherri Tenpenny,” Science-Based Medicine (Aug, 14, 2023).
[7] In re Sherri J. Tenpenny, D.O., Case No. 22-CRF-0168 State Medical Board of Ohio (Aug. 9, 2023).
[8] David Gorski, “The American Board of Internal Medicine finally acts against two misinformation-spreading doctors,” Science-Based Medicine (Aug. 7, 2023).
